Field Crops News
Resistant Sorghum Cultivars Affect Convergent Lady Beetle
It is often assumed that plant resistance to insects and biological control are two
compatible nonchemical controls that can be used in integrated pest management systems. This
assumption was tested with grain sorghum, greenbugs and convergent lady beetles. Greenbugs
were reared on 3 grain sorghum hybrids (2 resistant; Dekalb DK-41Y, DK-59E, and 1
susceptible; Horizon 101G) and then fed to convergent lady beetle for all of their larval
development. Lady beetles fed on greenbugs from resistant sorghums took significantly longer to
complete larval development (although this difference was only about 0.1 day), and had significantly lower survival (5-21%
lower, dependent on hybrid). Female convergent lady beetles weighed significantly less when fed
greenbugs from one resistant sorghum hybrid, but not when fed on another. These studies point
to the need to carefully evaluate interactions between control practices. Benefits of resistant
sorghums include decreasing greenbug survival and reproduction and increasing the development
period of greenbugs, which must be balanced with the negative effects on convergent lady
beetles documented in this study.
M. E. Rice & G. E. Wilde. 1989. Antibiosis effect of sorghum on the convergent lady beetle, a third-trophic
level predator of the greenbug. J. Econ. Entomol. 82: 570-573.
Trichogramma nubilalis Best for European Corn Borer Control
Losey & Calvin (1995) studied four commercially available species of Trichogramma (T.
pretiosum, T. platneri, T. minutum and an undescribed Trichogramma species from Georgia) in
comparison with T. nubilalis to determine their efficacy in parasitizing European corn borer
eggs. T. nubilalis is known to be an effective parasitoid of European corn borer, but is not
available commercially. In 24 hour laboratory tests, only 5 and 10% of T. pretiosum and T. sp.
(Georgia), respectively, laid eggs in corn borer eggs. T. minutum and T. platneri did not
parasitize any corn borer eggs. In contrast, 58% of T. nubilalis females parasitized at least a
portion of egg mass to which they were exposed, and parasitized the highest proportion (66%) of
eggs in each mass of any species. Although T. nubilalis is more expensive to rear, it is a better
candidate for control of corn borers than the other species tested. In fact, the performance of the
commercial species tested was so poor that the advisability of purchasing them at any price to
control corn borers is questionable.
J. E. Losey & D. D. Calvin. 1995. Quality assessment of four commercially available species of
Trichogramma. J. Econ. Entomol. 88(5): 1243-1250.
Return to Commodity Menu Vol. III No. 1
Return to Contents Menu Vol. III No. 1
Go To Index